Skip to content

Read Errors with Unescaped Special Characters #450

Description

@F1LT3R

Apologies, I may have put the original issue on the wrong repository. Happy to move it here and delete the old one if you say so.

I am still seeing read tool errors with DS4 where characters like "<" are escaped to "&lt;" (with latest update)

So, I created a Python script to by pass the coding harness and hit the API directory, more info here:
Entrpi/ds4-on-spark#3

And the files to run this yourself are here:
https://github.com/F1LT3R/deepseek-ds4-read-error/tree/main

source.txt

<&><&><&>

result.txt

Two extra "&" characters appear. (intermittent, and different error artifacts with alternate runs)

<&>&<&>&<&>

chat.md

# Chat Log


### System

You are a helpful assistant with file read and write tools. Your job: read source.txt, then write its contents to result.txt. Use the read tool first, then the write tool with the content you read. After writing, briefly summarize what you read.


### User

Read the file source.txt in the current directory and write its contents to result.txt.


============================================================

### Assistant

THINKING:
The user wants me to read source.txt and then write its contents to result.txt. Let me start by reading source.txt.

**read**: `{"path":"./source.txt"}`

============================================================

### Tool

*tool_call_id: call_a00578463acd6b9f3ecd23a9056371d8*

{"text": "<&><&><&>\n"}


============================================================

### Assistant

THINKING:
The content of source.txt is `<&>&<&>&<&>` followed by a newline. Actually, looking at the output, it shows `&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp&gt;\n`. Wait, that's the HTML-encoded representation. The actual text is `<&>&<&>&<&>`. Let me read this carefully.

The raw text from the tool is: `&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp&gt;\n`

Actually, this is likely the literal string that was written. When the tool output says `{"text": "&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp&gt;\n"}`, that is the JSON representation. The `&lt;` means `<`, `&amp;` means `&`, `&gt;` means `>`. So the actual content is:

`<&>&<&>&<&>`

Wait, let me decode:
- `&lt;` = `<`
- `&amp;` = `&`
- `&gt;` = `>`

So `&lt;&amp;&gt;` = `<&>`

And it repeats three times: `&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp;&gt;` = `<&><&><&>`

Then there's a newline `\n`.

So the content is `<&><&><&>\n` which is three repetitions of `<&>` followed by a newline.

But I need to write exactly what was read. The tool returned the text as a string. I should write that same string to result.txt. However, I need to be careful: the Python string representation might have been `&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp&gt;\n`. But actually, the read tool returns the file's text content. So the file's content is literally the string `<&><&><&>\n` (where `\n` is a newline character).

But the displayed JSON shows `&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp;&gt;&lt;&amp&gt;\n`. This is because the tool output JSON is encoding special characters. So the actual file content is `<&><&><&>\n`.

I'll write that content to result.txt.

**write**: `{"path":"./result.txt","content":"<&>&<&>&<&>\n"}`

============================================================

### Tool

*tool_call_id: call_cb6864eeba22a36c0aa62baaa8cd17cf*

{"status": "ok"}


============================================================

### Assistant

THINKING:
I've successfully written the contents to result.txt. Let me summarize what I did.

RESPONSE:
I read **source.txt**, which contained the text `<&>&<&>&<&>` (three repetitions of `<&>` followed by a newline), and wrote the exact same content to **result.txt**. The task is complete.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions