[JUDGE-PARSE-ERROR] Review needed: Test hook functionality

[AlexMikhalev]

Judge Evaluation Requires Human Review

Reason: invalid-json
Task ID: hook-test

Files Evaluated

/home/alex/.claude/hooks/pre_tool_use.sh

Scores Comparison

Round	Model	Verdict	Semantic	Pragmatic	Syntactic	Average
1	opencode/gpt-5-nano	improve	4	4	2	3.33

Full Verdict History

{"task_id": "hook-test", "model": "opencode/gpt-5-nano", "mode": "quick", "verdict": "improve", "scores": {"semantic": 4, "pragmatic": 4, "syntactic": 2}, "average": 3.33, "reasoning": "The script is semantically faithful to a pre-tool hook with guard and KG replacement, but a trailing non-comment line at the end renders it syntactically invalid.", "improvements": [], "timestamp": "2026-02-22T10:49:16Z", "round": 1, "judge_tier": "quick", "previous_rounds": [], "consensus": null, "human_override": null}

Action Needed

Human review and decision required. To override the automated verdict:

automation/judge/handle-disagreement.sh \
    --task-id "hook-test" \
    --override accept   # or reject

This will append a human override record to the verdicts log.