Judge Evaluation Requires Human Review
Reason: persistent-reject
Task ID: unknown
Files Evaluated
automation/judge/run-judge.sh docs/handover-judge-v2.md
Scores Comparison
| Round |
Model |
Verdict |
Semantic |
Pragmatic |
Syntactic |
Average |
| 1 |
? |
reject |
1 |
1 |
2 |
1.33 |
Full Verdict History
{"verdict": "reject", "scores": {"semantic": 1, "pragmatic": 1, "syntactic": 2}, "average": 1.33, "reasoning": "The provided output is the run-judge.sh script content, not the requested handover documentation reference. It fails to address the task description, lacks a proper handover summary, and does not present a valid JSON verdict payload reflecting the handover requirement.", "improvements": [], "task_id": "unknown", "round": 1, "judge_tier": "quick", "previous_rounds": [], "consensus": null, "human_override": null}
Action Needed
Human review and decision required. To override the automated verdict:
automation/judge/handle-disagreement.sh \
--task-id "unknown" \
--override accept # or reject
This will append a human override record to the verdicts log.
Judge Evaluation Requires Human Review
Reason: persistent-reject
Task ID: unknown
Files Evaluated
automation/judge/run-judge.sh docs/handover-judge-v2.md
Scores Comparison
Full Verdict History
{"verdict": "reject", "scores": {"semantic": 1, "pragmatic": 1, "syntactic": 2}, "average": 1.33, "reasoning": "The provided output is the run-judge.sh script content, not the requested handover documentation reference. It fails to address the task description, lacks a proper handover summary, and does not present a valid JSON verdict payload reflecting the handover requirement.", "improvements": [], "task_id": "unknown", "round": 1, "judge_tier": "quick", "previous_rounds": [], "consensus": null, "human_override": null}Action Needed
Human review and decision required. To override the automated verdict:
automation/judge/handle-disagreement.sh \ --task-id "unknown" \ --override accept # or rejectThis will append a human override record to the verdicts log.