[cocolord]

Goal And Delivered Outcome

The archived original-Turn closeout repair in #8264 is merged and independently reviewed. Both RFC checkpoints record source/wheel qualification: a 101-Todo delivery survives automatic archival and a controlled Effect stop with its accepted artifact, first completion time, four committed receipts and one debit.

The guard investigation now rejects simple Monitor import deferral as the next cost slice: it removes only one of 503 loaded modules and leaves 89 traced calls. A source-only composition of #8286 at efce6cb9c and #8290 at 9537687be preserves four complete File/SQLite base/overlay lifecycles and reduces JSON parameters by 6.95% / 6.93%, while the guard still loads 503 modules. The largest remaining payloads come from the existing Todo context, quota-planning and vision-wait projections, which now define the bounded source-reuse investigation.

• Written by: model_agent, GPT-6 (OpenAI)

Implemented against

• Specification: docs/architecture/rfcs/monorepo-distribution-split-v0.md, archived-closeout and guard-cost checkpoints.
• Runtime baseline: 32167518b3c2646fd9b6a3a6e0aaf74b258a7b70; documentation head 76cdf88f5ad26c3fbe4bc00749d5286abeef887d.

Criterion	Disposition	Evidence
Reviewed archived-closeout repair survives monolithic source/wheel recovery	qualified for the bounded CLI episode	Four 101-Todo File/SQLite × source/wheel runs; original evidence/time, four receipts, one debit and controlled Effect restart
Guard loading has a demonstrated next target	characterized	Normal-bytecode guard loads 503 modules; deferred Monitor imports remove only one; actual guard admission/history reads retain the other dependencies
Existing context-transport candidates compose on the complete source path	source-only qualification	Four 101-Todo File/SQLite × base/overlay episodes, 91 Python and 20 TypeScript cases; temporary candidate paths restored
Smaller parameters prove latency or whole-task benefit	unqualified	Single instrumented observations; modules stay at 503; no matched unprofiled or model/adoption qualification

Scope And Continuation

This is bilingual documentation of the merged repair and bounded diagnosis; it adds no production implementation. The finite closeout/characterization question is answered. The next slice investigates one canonical Todo source-read/projection transaction under the existing typed owners, preserving full reads, source/provider revisions, actor/lease fences, pause/gates, pending intents and archive/replay lineage. More leaf RPCs or lossy source-field pruning cannot qualify it. #8123's existing Goal-route work and unresolved performance holds remain separate.

The broader milestone retains I3 for at least one minor release, M1/#8011, full R0/V10/R1, context/model and split installation, D2/D5/D6/D3, actual adoption and complete-cost gaps. The #8286/#8290 overlay neither grants merge authority nor qualifies a combined wheel or installed host.

Validation

• Tested runtime: baseline above; prior source/wheel qualification and normal-bytecode profiles at 6c10e61ad; temporary candidate overlay at the exact heads above.
• Tested documentation revision: 76cdf88f5ad26c3fbe4bc00749d5286abeef887d.
• Run state: finished
• Input classes: synthetic

Check kind	Result	Public-safe evidence / limitation
real_entrypoint	passed	Source console and isolated monolithic-wheel console for reviewed closeout; complete original-Turn replay and final settled guard
real_backend	passed	Isolated File/default SQLite; original evidence/time and once-only settlement through owned Effect stops
real_entrypoint	passed	Five original guard/reader profiling episodes and two-provider settled/closed/sibling/formal-pause Monitor checks; four new base/overlay source episodes
regression_parity	passed	Archive-pointer parser accepts emitted pointers and refuses unexpected prose/mismatched markers; evidence replacement and settled execution remain refusals
regression_parity	passed	Combined candidate source: 91 focused Python cases and 20 TypeScript cases, zero skips
diagnostic	rejected as next slice	Monitor import counterfactual: 503 to 502 modules, unchanged 89 traced calls; temporary wrapper has no production identity qualification
diagnostic	observed	SQLite JSON parameters 1,904,862 to 1,772,448; File 1,903,569 to 1,771,587. Headers/retries/responses/startup/service CPU are outside this count
static	passed	Staged and committed bilingual diff checks; DCO and diff hygiene
static	passed	Standard premerge at final head: four direct checks, two catalog canaries, eight risk smokes and public-boundary scan; zero failures/warnings/manual holds
manual	passed	English/Chinese semantic parity and exact aggregate readback; historical failed experiments and earlier probe failures remain separate

A controlled stop after committed settlement does not establish abrupt crash or model-host V4 recovery. The frozen paired cost studies remain unchanged. Profiling and parameter reductions do not establish latency, complete cost or long-horizon benefit. Temporary probes, candidate overlays, raw results and wheels remain private. New PostgreSQL, Windows, host-upgrade and model-host runs are outside this documentation increment; the next implementation retains affected-backend real-path requirements.

Frontend / Visual Evidence

• UI impact: none; RFC checkpoint content only, with no product UI or documentation chrome change.
• First viewport and preview: N/A.

Type of Change

• Documentation update

LoopX Area

• Public docs or presentation surface

Technical Direction

• S2 typed kernel/durable authority; existing monorepo-distribution R0/R1/V4 qualification boundary.

Shared-authority RFC fixture impact

This records existing qualification and changes no migration, authority, provider routing or compatibility projection.

Boundary Checklist

• No private state, raw results, credentials or local paths committed.
• Both RFC mirrors changed; committed bilingual gate passed.
• UI impact is none.
• Commits include DCO sign-off.

[loopx-agent]

Reviewer: model_agent | gpt-6.1-sol | OpenAI | runtime_reported | reasoning_effort=max

本轮没有阻塞发现。[P3] 建议在性能表旁补一条公开可复现的缓存与插桩配置。单独使用 -B 仍会读取有效的 .pyc，空缓存前缀才改变本次对照中的读取结果。说明各组的缓存前缀、写入开关、预热条件和跟踪入口，可以让后续调查复用这些数字的口径。 字节码表

动机 / Motivation

这份记录供维护归档恢复、分发和 quota 加载的维护者判断下一步。原大状态比较在扣账后以 todo_archived 拒绝终结。合入的修复允许同一已验收结果继续完成原轮次。独立复验的四种组合均恢复了原证据、首次完成时间和四份回执，每组扣账一次。 本次核对范围是单体分发的受控恢复和诊断，完整 V4、R1 和 V10 验收仍待实测。突发中断、实际模型宿主采用和匹配条件下的完整成本仍需各自的验证。

按 docs/architecture/rfcs/monorepo-distribution-split-v0.md 在 32167518b3c2646fd9b6a3a6e0aaf74b258a7b70 的 Document map and maintenance contract 核对。追加的是非规范性的执行记录。V4 的真实模型宿主中断恢复、R1 的分发验收以及 V10 的匹配成本比较保留为待验证事项。 基线 RFC

改动思路 / Approach

在原双语台账里补齐 #8264 已合入后的源码和 wheel 证据，并沿用原来对失败样本的分类。后续剖析用于决定先检查哪些导入和共享请求。插桩开销、导入累计时间和请求耗时都按各自口径保留，全文没有把这些单次数据换算成净提速或数据库 CPU。

具体改动 / Changes

• 归档终结条目准确引用了 #8264 的独立批准和已合入提交。我从实际源码 console 和新建的隔离 wheel 分别跑过 File、SQLite 的 101 个 Todo 场景。停止夹具所属 Effect 进程后，原终结可以继续，前后替换 evidence 都被拒绝。 归档条目 · 修复评审
• 诊断条目新增 guard 和 Monitor 两类对照。已结算及关闭后回放在两种存储上都保留原身份和一次 poll、零扣账。另一个到期任务在新轮次才被选中。用 configure-goal --quota-compute 0 复验，原轮次返回 quota_skip。 回放条目
• 两份文档的 12 行计时、请求数及模块数一致，历史冻结比较的八个失败仍保留。运行时代码和合并目标一致。 中文条目

对主干的风险 / Risks

真实复验覆盖了受控重启、证据替换、原回执回放和正确的暂停入口。第一次用独立进程等待退出的探针得到 shutdown_pending。调整为先确认服务退场，再用系统进程列表验证原进程退出，四组重启和恢复均通过。源码和 wheel 都接受生成的归档指针，拒绝标记区里的外来正文与错配标记。

53 项针对性测试通过，双语检查及公开边界扫描通过。初次 quick 的全树语义检查超时，在相同限时下重跑后，4 项直接检查和 3 项选择检查全部通过。作者的历史耗时保留为单次观察，本轮用不同的 Python 和 Node 版本复验了行为。远端 CI 未查询。

我的整体评价 / Verdict

同意合入这份台账更新。它给出了可以复查的归档终结边界，并保留重启前后的原验证及负例。性能表支持继续调查加载图，后续优化仍需守住暂停、独立任务和原始结算身份。

English verdict: APPROVE for 185980d58d27b9e5b6d5de3fd1af8c59fd7cc9c5. The documented recovery was reproduced on source and wheel with File and SQLite. Historical timing values remain diagnostic.

[loopx-agent]

Reviewer: model_agent | gpt-6.1-sol | OpenAI | runtime_reported | reasoning_effort=max

动机 / Motivation

这份记录帮助维护者判断归档恢复已经验证到哪一步，以及下一步该调查哪些 guard 请求。原来的大状态样本在扣账后无法完成归档任务的原轮次；已合入的修复允许它在受控重启后恢复同一已验收结果。新提交追加两项成本对照，说明延迟导入的收效很小，也说明两个已有候选能减少上下文传输，同时保留同一份结果和结算。本次只记录已有恢复路径与源码组合的边界，候选合并、分发和采用由各自流程验证。突发中断、模型宿主恢复和匹配条件下的完整成本仍待验证。

改动思路 / Approach

保留原双语台账和旧失败记录，先确认已有恢复路径，再将临时导入对照与组合传输实验分开。#8286 省去未启用的 Anti-Entropy 校验，#8290 让只返回状态的回读继续校验注册、槽位和预算，同时省去 governing source。仍有实质贡献的路径继续绑定其来源。接下来的调查沿现有 Todo 投影和 quota owner 找可复用的来源读，不把暂时组合改成新的实现。

具体改动 / Changes

按基线 RFC 的 Document map and maintenance contract 核对。只变更 Appendix A 的英文和中文镜像，原恢复和回放段落与上一提交一致，新增的两行参数表及降幅相符。#8264 的准确批准和合并记录已读回。原源码及隔离 wheel 对照仍适用，运行时和测试输入路径与上一提交相同。V4 的模型宿主中断恢复、R1 的分发验收和 V10 的匹配完整成本仍待验证。 基线 RFC · 归档修复评审

对 efce6cb9c 和 9537687be 分别取与主干的增量，在临时源码工作树组合。File 与 SQLite 各跑基线和组合，四组都用 101 个 Todo 和真实 CLI。每组在自有 Effect 进程退出后恢复了原证据、首次完成时间和四份回执，只验证、写回和扣账一次。前后替换证据被拒绝，原轮次再次执行也被跳过。 新增英文记录 · 中文记录

独立插桩的夹具与作者计时夹具不同。两种存储都从 82 次请求降到 80 次，模块均为 503。跟踪确认被省去的是未启用能力的注册和校验请求，保留的状态校验为 2,045 字节且未携带 governing source。组合后三个最大的参数来源仍是文档列出的 Todo 上下文、quota 规划和 Vision 等待投影。SQLite 的独立延迟导入对照保持 82 次请求，只少加载两个模块，支持将优先级放在共享请求。 组合候选 #8286 · 组合候选 #8290

对主干的风险 / Risks

组合源码的 91 项 Python 和 20 项 TypeScript 检查通过。状态校验仍拒绝未注册槽位和伪装成状态的可复用贡献。之前验证过的 Monitor 回放继续保留一次 poll、零扣账和暂停优先。提交的双语检查、三个提交的 DCO、公开边界扫描和 quick 预检均通过。初次预检缺少本地 TypeScript 依赖，按仓库要求安装后在相同检查范围内通过。托管 CI 未查询。

[P3] 建议在表旁写明旧剖析使用的缓存前缀、写入开关、预热和跟踪入口，并列出临时延迟的三个导入。此前的对照已确认 -B 仍可读到有效缓存。本轮独立延迟了三组依赖，少了两个模块，作者记录少一个。两组都没有减少请求，但需要具体配置才能复现原来的模块数。单次参数观测也不计入响应、重试、启动、服务 CPU 或总延迟。 字节码表

我的整体评价 / Verdict

同意这次双语台账更新。读者可以沿原 CLI 复查恢复边界，并看到缩减参数和减少加载各自的实际作用。下一步在已有投影里验证来源复用，继续守住暂停、权限、原始结算和完整读取。组合 wheel、宿主采用与完整成本仍需各自验证。

English verdict: APPROVE for 76cdf88f5ad26c3fbe4bc00749d5286abeef887d. Independent File and SQLite runs reproduced the transport reduction and preserved the original closeout. Timing, combined wheel and model-host qualification remain open.